Are crazy questions actually useful?

Are crazy questions actually useful?


What vegetable would you be? Why are manholes round? Teach me something I don’t know. There are all kinds of tactics for getting to the heart of your candidates knowledge, creativity and problem solving skills, but is asking something that open-ended and high-pressure, especially in an interview setting, really useful?

Financial Times columnist Lucy Kellaway says no – it just causes stress and confusion. The final question, routinely asked by Google CEO Larry Page, was asked at the Hay Festival and a panel of writers struggled, with one saying they didn’t know anything other people didn’t know and whatever he used to know he’d forgotten.

“Listening to this, I changed my mind,” Kellaway said. “Mr. Page’s question isn’t great at all. It is as hopeless as all the other things people ask applicants.”

The theory goes that by asking a question the applicant isn’t prepared for, the answer will carry more meaning compared to things like “Tell me about a time you showed courage.”

Kellaway lists some of the oddball offerings collected by, including these gems:

  • If you were shrunk to the size of a pencil and put in a blender how would you get out? (Goldman Sachs)
  • What do you think of garden gnomes? (Trader Joe’s)
  • If you were a Microsoft Office program, which would it be? (an unnamed auto repair shop)

As fun as these might be to ask – especially if you enjoy making interviewees sweat – studies show the results are little better than picking people at random.

The question “What is 37 times 37?” might show some useful information about a candidate, Kellowar added, but she suggested interviewers ditch the off-the-wall approach if they want to get more than a look of terror from candidates.

What are the strangest interview questions you’ve ever asked or been asked? Do you see redeeming factors in this kind of approach?


Have your say

Do you condone office romances?

Latest News

Outwit, outplay, outlast: US lawyer auditions new hires
C-Suite execs say HR struggling to adapt
Handling employee complaints and grievances effectively
Paranoia is feeding fear of flexible work policies: report

Most Discussed

Beauty barriers: are you judging candidates by their hair and nails?
Bullying audits could prevent the blame game
“Unconscionable” signed release thrown out by court